Twenty injuries, old and new, tell the story of a 13-year-old girl’s death at FIA official’s Islamabad home

Twenty injuries, old and new, tell the story of a 13-year-old girl’s death at FIA official’s Islamabad home

By Staff Reporter

ISLAMABAD: A 13-year-old girl who died after being taken from the Islamabad residence of a senior federal investigator had been subjected to repeated physical assaults, a post-mortem examination has concluded.

The autopsy on Fatima Asghar documented 20 injuries, all suspected to have been caused by beatings. It found that she died of grievous injuries and severe inflammation, which led to thromboembolism, a blood vessel blocked by a clot, and then to cardiopulmonary arrest, the failure of the heart and lungs.

“All injuries were inflicted before death and were sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of life,” the report said.

Police sources said the injuries were a mixture of old, new and healed wounds, which pointed to repeated violence rather than a single episode. The report listed swelling on the left side of the head near the temple, a blood clot on the right side and a bald patch on the right side of the scalp. Her left cheek was swollen and had lost skin, and two old, healed scars marked the right.

The examiners recorded bruising and swelling on both hands and wrists, and wounds on the left arm. They also found old, linear dark marks on the chest and lower abdomen, an old, unhealed burn near the left shoulder blade, and older burn scars across her back. Her knees and left thigh were darkened and swollen, and a wound on the outer left knee had not healed.

Swelling extended across the head from the left temple to the back, with internal bleeding. Samples of the heart, lungs, liver, blood and stomach contents, whole-body X-rays and a brain CT scan have been passed to police for analysis.

An Islamabad court on Monday granted police four days’ physical remand of Afshan Ali, wife of Muhammad bin Ashraf, the FIA’s Gujranwala zone director, and of Ali Raza, a Quran teacher. Police told the court that CCTV footage shows the two beating Fatima with sticks. Investigators said the sticks had been recovered from the suspects. The FIA is Pakistan’s main federal law enforcement agency.

Inspector Nadeem Mughal of the Homicide Investigation Unit told the court that further investigation and evidence were needed. Police sources said that in early questioning Ali claimed the girl died after eating fertiliser, which initial medical findings do not support. The suspects have not yet entered a plea, and the allegations against them are untested.

The case was registered on Sunday at Shams Colony police station under Section 302 of the Pakistan Penal Code, which covers intentional murder, on the complaint of Fatima’s father. On the day the FIR was registered, the FIA ordered Ashraf to report to its headquarters with immediate effect. Local media have reported that he has been suspended from his post. He has not been named as a suspect in the reports reviewed.

In the complaint, the girl’s father, a resident of Rahim Yar Khan, said his daughter was a seminary student living with close relatives at Police Lines Headquarters in Islamabad’s H-11 sector. He said he was told in the morning that she had suddenly fallen ill and been taken to hospital, where she died.

An Islamabad police officer said Fatima had worked as a domestic help at the official’s residence for a couple of years, since he served in the capital police. However, the FIR does not explicitly say she was employed there. Police sources said the family had come under pressure to settle, but her father pursued legal action.

First Lady Bibi Asifa Bhutto Zardari expressed sorrow over the death and said no child should be subjected to violence, abuse or exploitation. She noted that Islamabad’s child employment law, enacted four years ago, bars the employment of children of Fatima’s age as domestic workers, even with parental consent. The law, she said, must be enforced in letter and spirit.

She called for a thorough, impartial and transparent investigation, urged that those responsible be brought to justice, and said vulnerable children working in homes must be protected through collective effort.

The case is likely to renew scrutiny of a practice that remains widespread. A 2022 International Labour Organization report found that one in four Pakistani households employs a child in domestic work, mostly girls aged 10 to 14. In 2018, a court sentenced a judge and his wife to three years in jail for torturing a 10-year-old maid in Islamabad, but reports of abuse of domestic servants have continued.

Copyright © 2021 Independent Pakistan | All rights reserved

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *