By Staff Reporter
ISLAMABAD: Eight members of the Pakistan Bar Council have called on the judiciary to enforce a Supreme Court order moving the jailed former prime minister Imran Khan to a private hospital, warning that the government and its agencies alone will be responsible for imperilling the lives of Khan and his wife, Bushra Bibi.
The statement, issued on Tuesday, followed an open letter sent on Monday by Khan to the chief justices of the Federal Constitutional Court (FCC), the Supreme Court and the Islamabad High Court. In it, the 74-year-old said he would be able to prove his innocence in the cases against him only “if I stay alive”. The letter was released by his lawyer, Salman Safdar, who said he prepared it from instructions Khan gave him during a three-hour meeting at Adiala jail on 11 November.
“We call upon the judiciary to take up the former prime minister’s plea immediately and to save his and his wife’s lives by ensuring that court orders are implemented, that proper medical treatment is provided and that due process and a fair trial are guaranteed as mandated by the Constitution,” the lawyers said.
The statement was signed by Abid Shahid Zuberi, Muhammad Maqsood Buttar, Shafqat Mehmood Chauhan, Abdul Sattar Khan, Munir Ahmed Kakar, Salman Akram Raja, Salahuddin Ahmed and Qazi Muhammad Arshad.
They said they reserved the right to go to court themselves. “We the undersigned reserve our right to initiate legal proceedings to protect the life, liberty, and constitutional and legal rights of Imran and Bushra Bibi,” they said.
The signatories condemned “in the strongest terms” what they called the unlawful and unconstitutional treatment of the couple. They said the situation endangered their lives, liberty and dignity.
They said Khan’s letter showed that the couple had been denied their constitutional and human rights “through trumped-up and false cases” and were being held in violation of the law, the jail manual and the prison rules. Their appeals against conviction had not been heard, the lawyers said, and “even their bail applications have not been fixed for hearing”.
The statement also alleged that Khan had been kept in solitary confinement and denied medical treatment and access to his legal team and family. It said his sisters had been detained arbitrarily and unlawfully, and that the government and its agencies had openly flouted the Supreme Court’s 18 August order.
“Every person in Pakistan is guaranteed the right to life and liberty under Article 9, and the right to due process and a fair trial under Article 10-A of the Constitution,” the statement said. “These rights have been denied to Imran, his wife, his family and his party members.”
It ended with a rebuke aimed as much at the state as at the courts. “As patriotic Pakistanis who believe in the rule of law, we are ashamed to read Imran’s plea for implementation of the SC’s orders and for the proper medical treatment that has been denied to him and his wife,” it said.
On 18 August, a three-member Supreme Court bench directed the government to move Khan to Shifa International Hospital in Islamabad within two days. The order also called for him to be examined by a medical board that included a cardiologist and an eye specialist. The government instead took him to the state-run Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences (PIMS) for a check-up and returned him to prison. At the time, the information minister, Attaullah Tarar, blamed the security situation created by PTI workers on the way to and outside the hospital; the party denied this and accused the government of deliberately ignoring the court.
In his letter, Khan wrote that the order had not been implemented. He said he had lost 85 per cent of the vision in his right eye and that doctors had warned him he was highly vulnerable to a brain haemorrhage and cardiac arrest. He put his blood pressure at 192 and 193 on 10 November, after months of solitary confinement, and expressed particular fear for Bushra Bibi, who he said could lose her sight permanently without a second eye operation.
Khan was taken to hospital again late on 10 November for an eye injection. PIMS described him as clinically stable.
The government rejects the claim that he is being neglected. The parliamentary affairs minister, Tariq Fazal Chaudhry, said the letter was contrary to the facts and appeared to be an attempt to achieve political objectives. He said Khan had been taken to PIMS eight times, that his blood pressure had been assessed as satisfactory, and that he was one of the most privileged prisoners in the country. He also said Khan was in prison because of his conviction in the £190m corruption case, not political victimisation. Khan’s party, the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), says his convictions are politically motivated.
The bar members were not alone on Tuesday. The Democratic Alliance, a confederation of lawyers led by the former Pakistan Bar Council vice chairman Abid Saqi, said it was gravely alarmed by the deteriorating health and unlawful detention conditions of Khan and his family. It asked the judiciary to take immediate notice and enforce its orders on medical treatment and family access, and urged the government to end his solitary confinement and release relatives it said were held without cause. It also called on the international community and human rights groups to take urgent cognisance of the situation.
“The life of a former prime minister and his family hang in the balance,” the alliance said. “Justice delayed is justice denied. The Democratic Alliance demands that the rule of law and human dignity prevail before it is too late.”
The Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP) said it was deeply concerned by the state’s treatment of political prisoners and that the allegations in Khan’s letter needed urgent and independent examination.
“HRCP stresses that violations of political prisoners’ fundamental freedoms are not a matter of personalities or political affiliations; they constitute an assault on the rule of law,” the commission said. “Every prisoner is entitled to humane treatment, adequate healthcare, access to family and lawyers, and a fair trial. All relevant court orders must be implemented and allegations of mistreatment independently investigated.”
The eight lawyers do not speak for the council as a whole. In August, after the same group condemned the government’s handling of the Supreme Court order, the council’s vice chairman, Pir Muhammad Masood Chistie, said their statement reflected only the views of those eight of its 23 members and distanced the council from it.
Lawyers for Bushra Bibi, who has been in jail since January 2025, filed an application at the Islamabad High Court on Monday seeking her full medical record and an immediate transfer to a specialist hospital. Khan’s own case, he wrote, is awaiting a hearing before the FCC.
Copyright © 2021 Independent Pakistan | All rights reserved
