Police file Hina Javed murder case after three-month wait, but family still demands judicial inquiry

Police file Hina Javed murder case after three-month wait, but family still demands judicial inquiry

By Staff Reporter

ISLAMABAD: Police investigating the murder of Hina Javed, a 45-year-old digital media executive found dead in her Rawalpindi home, have filed their case in court after a delay of almost three months that drew rebukes from prosecutors and a judge.

Sardar Ghias Gul, the city’s newly appointed police chief, told reporters on Saturday that the investigation was complete and the charge sheet, known in Pakistan as a challan, had been sent for further legal proceedings. He acknowledged shortcomings in police prosecution, saying suspects could be prevented from walking free if the right people were placed in the right positions.

According to police sources cited by local media, the document names Zeeshan Arshad, the family’s domestic worker, as the prime suspect. It includes DNA reports on all the suspects, mobile phone call records, forensic findings and the post-mortem report. Photographs of Javed recovered from Arshad’s phone are also said to be part of the file.

Her husband, Faisal Asghar, was arrested alongside Arshad within days of the killing. Both men were sent to Adiala jail on judicial remand in early September. Neither has been convicted.

Under Pakistani law, police must submit a charge sheet in a murder case within 15 days of a suspect being remanded to judicial custody. By 15 November, 86 days after the killing, the Rawalpindi District Prosecution Branch had issued notices to the city police chief and the senior superintendent of police for investigation, demanding an explanation. An additional district and sessions judge had also asked for the document. The investigating officer countered that the case had already been through three separate inquiries, including one by the Crime Control Department and another by a parliamentary committee.

Javed was found on the morning of 20 August in the bathroom of a second-floor flat at Askari Apartments in the Lal Kurti area, according to the police complaint. Reports citing it said she had been gagged, her hands tied behind her back and a wire wrapped around her neck. There was an injury below her right lip and bleeding from her nose. The Rawalpindi police chief at the time ruled out suicide.

Her brother, Fahad Javed, filed the complaint accusing her husband, her father-in-law and the domestic worker of killing her. The father-in-law was questioned but not arrested.

Forensic evidence has been central. DNA from Arshad matched postmortem swabs taken from Javed’s body, as well as other samples from the scene. Her husband’s DNA matched samples from several items at the scene. A Y-STR profile taken from her clothing showed a mixture from at least three people, and the husband, father-in-law and domestic worker could not be ruled out as contributors.

Local media, citing police sources, has reported that a rape charge was added after DNA findings reportedly indicated sexual assault.

Javed’s family has not accepted the police account. It has repeatedly said it has no confidence in the Rawalpindi investigation and rejected the findings of the Crime Control Department inquiry, accusing investigators of favouring the husband. Relatives claim to hold proof that the husband’s brother cleaned the accused’s room, tampered with evidence and colluded with police. They have demanded a special judicial commission and access to the DNA and forensic reports, which have not been made public. In an open letter to Punjab Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz last month, they urged her to establish the commission.

Arshad’s father has said his son is innocent and is being framed as the main accused. Local media visited the family’s home village in Mandi Bahauddin district found no earlier police case or complaint against him on record, though the investigation team has publicly described him as having criminal tendencies. Police have said he confessed.

The case has reached the highest levels of government. The Punjab government set up a three-member committee to review the investigation. The National Assembly Standing Committee on Interior and Narcotics Control summoned senior police officials, including the Punjab police chief, to brief it. Nawaz has said that “DNA test results and polygraph test suggest that the murder and rape were committed by the servant; however the investigation is ongoing”.

On 29 October, the First Lady, Aseefa Bhutto Zardari, met Javed’s family at Parliament and called for their demand for a judicial commission to be “given due consideration”. With the challan filed, the evidence will now be tested in court.

Copyright © 2021 Independent Pakistan | All rights reserved

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *