By Staff Reporter
ISLAMABAD: Pakistan’s highest courts have been brought under the effective control of the government by two constitutional amendments passed little more than a year apart, the International Commission of Jurists (ICJ) has said.
In a report published on Wednesday, the Geneva-based organisation found that the judiciary no longer enjoys the institutional guarantees of independence required under international law, describing the outcome as “systemic judicial capture” by other branches of the state.
Santiago Canton, the ICJ’s secretary general, said that once courts were captured, “no one is left to hold the government to account” and victims of human rights violations had “nowhere to turn”.
The report, titled ‘Judicial Capture: Independence of the Judiciary in Pakistan after the 26th and 27th Constitutional Amendments’, examines the High Courts, the Supreme Court and the new Federal Constitutional Court (FCC). It calls the amendments a “decisive break” from the model of judicial independence Pakistan built after the judiciary was restored in 2009.
The ICJ noted that the damage was done through constitutional amendments rather than the overt removal of judges.
The 26th Amendment, passed in October 2024, carved constitutional benches out of the Supreme Court. It also reconstituted the Judicial Commission of Pakistan (JCP), which selects the members of those benches, so that judges no longer held a majority. It gave a parliamentary committee the power to pick the chief justice from among the three most senior judges.
A little over a year later, the 27th Amendment turned those benches into a separate Federal Constitutional Court. The same law made Field Marshal Syed Asim Munir the Chief of Defence Forces and granted lifetime immunity to the president and the army chief.
Supreme Court judges Mansoor Ali Shah and Athar Minallah resigned within hours of President Asif Ali Zardari signing it. Justice Shah called the amendment a “grave assault on the Constitution”. A Lahore High Court judge, Shams Mehmood Mirza, resigned days later.
The government has argued that the changes were needed to “check judicial overreach”, reduce the case backlog, end the perceived politicisation of the Supreme Court’s original jurisdiction and give parliament a role in appointments comparable to that in other democracies.
The ICJ said none of this justified restructuring the courts in a way that was “glaringly inconsistent” with Pakistan’s obligations under international law.
The report did not defend the old system. It acknowledged that the Supreme Court had “encroached into roles of Parliament and other institutions”. But it said parliament had failed to fix those faults in a way that preserved judicial independence.
“Pakistan’s judiciary needed reform,” Canton said. By his account, the government used public frustration with the courts as a “pretext” to bring them under its “full control”.
The report found that the ruling coalition had “exploited” public grievances over the courts in a “self-serving manner”. As a result, it said, even the highest courts “no longer serve as a check on the executive or the Parliament”, and their role as a route to redress for victims of rights abuses is “seriously impaired”.
The ICJ also said the erosion of judicial independence has taken place alongside a wider backsliding of democracy and human rights protections in Pakistan.
It urged the government to begin a comprehensive review of both amendments under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), with “transparent and broad” public consultation. It also asked ministers to seek technical help from the UN special rapporteur on the independence of judges and lawyers, and to invite the rapporteur to visit.
Its recommendation goes further: provisions in the two amendments that conflict with international standards should be revised or repealed.
The report also set out specific demands for the bodies that now control the judiciary:
- Judicial Commission of Pakistan: publish its appointment criteria, make them the “sole basis” for nominating judges, give reasons for each appointment and stop transferring high court judges without their consent.
- Supreme Judicial Council: limit “inefficiency”, a ground for removing judges, to “serious incompetence that renders judges unfit to discharge their duties”.
- Special Parliamentary Committee: adopt “clear and transparent criteria and procedures” for choosing the chief justices of the Supreme Court and the FCC, and publish its reasons.
The government has defended the changes before. In January, Law Minister Azam Nazeer Tarar answered an Amnesty International report by arguing that the FCC had consolidated the federation rather than weakened judicial independence. A government response to the ICJ report was not immediately available.
The ICJ called the 27th Amendment a “flagrant attack” on judicial independence when it became law.
Its final recommendation is addressed to the judges themselves. The FCC, the Supreme Court and the high courts, it said, should apply both amendments “to the greatest extent possible” in a way that is consistent with the independence of the judiciary guaranteed by Article 14 of the ICCPR.
Copyright © 2021 Independent Pakistan | All rights reserved
