By Staff Reporter
ISLAMABAD: Senior leaders of the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) have accused defence minister Khawaja Asif of crossing a “red line” with personal attacks on its chairman, Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari, deepening a feud inside the country’s ruling coalition.
Senator Sherry Rehman and MP Sharmila Faruqui said on Sunday that Asif’s remarks were unacceptable. It was the latest exchange between the PPP and the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) of Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif, which leads the government with the PPP as its ally at the centre.
“Unacceptable flow of comments from the federal defence minister about the PPP organisation and our leadership, Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari,” Rehman wrote on X. “He has crossed a red line.”
Faruqui condemned Asif’s “derogatory language” and “irresponsible remarks” about the PPP chairman. “This is a red line for us,” she said.
She told the minister that everyone had the right to disagree politically, but that there was a difference between derision and disagreement.
“As a senior parliamentarian and a federal minister, you are expected to exercise political judgement, seriousness and decorum,” she said. “Political differences are addressed through reasoned argument, not personal attacks. Remember, words reflect not only a person’s character but also the dignity of their office.”
The two women were reacting to a post by Asif on 19 November, in which he shared two video clips of Bhutto-Zardari. In one, the PPP chairman criticises the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) and its founder, Imran Khan. In the other, taken from a recent speech at the Karachi Press Club, he calls the jailed former prime minister a “political prisoner”.
“A person becomes the prime minister and is later imprisoned,” Bhutto-Zardari says in the second clip. “So I can either accept that every prime minister in the country’s history has been a thief, or I can accept that all prime ministers in our history have been victims of political revenge.”
Asif’s comment on the footage was blunt. “We believed that the new generation would be better and more principled than ours,” he wrote. “Did not know they would turn out to be masters of dishonesty and change colours so remarkably.”
The dispute started from the Karachi Press Club speech on 17 November. Bhutto-Zardari addressed the debate over creating new provinces, backed several opposition demands and questioned decisions taken by the ruling coalition. He warned of bloodshed in Sindh if new provinces were created and called for a “political reset”.
Senior figures in the PML-N, Jamaat-i-Islami and the Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan accused him of “political hypocrisy”. Bhutto-Zardari later defended his right to criticise a system his party is part of, arguing that being a stakeholder gave him reason to propose solutions.
Asif’s replies have grown more personal. The day after the speech, he asked: “Are your own hands clean? Do you have the right to lecture others or issue threats?” He also remarked sarcastically that Sindh, which the PPP has governed for 18 years, had become “a paradise” and that the world envied Karachi’s condition.
He then turned to Bilawal House in Lahore, asking who owned the property and who lived there. Those without legal title to properties, he said, could not “morally claim any privileged position”, and the country’s 250 million people deserved to know the financial and property details of those who considered high status their entitlement.
On Saturday he called the PPP chairman the “biggest beneficiary” of the system and its critic at the same time. “You need to have some cheek to be the biggest beneficiary and a critic of the system at the same time,” he wrote. “Rank opportunism.”
He also shared a newspaper column examining the PPP’s record in Sindh, putting federal transfers to the province at Rs18,840 billion. “Have some shame, have some decency,” he wrote.
PPP figures have answered in kind. Nadeem Afzal Chan, a senior party leader, posted a video of workers gathering at Bilawal House, calling it the home of every party worker. “Show us people entering any other big house in the same way,” he said, addressing the minister. “Uncle… answer the questions, whether you like it or not.”
In a separate statement on X, the party accused Asif of trying to provoke it into personal attacks on the PML-N leadership. It said Bhutto-Zardari had told party leaders to ignore the minister and concentrate on issue-based politics. It added that the PPP was well aware of controversies surrounding the PML-N leadership and named the Panama Papers, Avenfield properties and Al-Azizia Steel Mills cases.
The sniping has continued despite efforts at the top to contain it. President Asif Ali Zardari, the PPP chairman’s father, and Sharif met on 14 and 19 November, the second time with interior minister Mohsin Naqvi present. The Presidency said on Thursday that they had agreed to resolve all matters through dialogue. They met again on Saturday to discuss the overall political situation.
Afterwards, Rehman urged the government to attend to people’s problems rather than create new political fault lines, and said ministers should avoid provocative statements.
“Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari is looking to prevent bloodshed, not shed it,” she said.
Bhutto-Zardari himself has aimed his remarks at ministers rather than the prime minister. Speaking in Karachi on Friday, he said he wanted Sharif to become the first prime minister in Pakistan’s history to complete a five-year term, and that his aim was to “strengthen the hand of the prime minister”. He said Sharif had not been given the chance to concentrate on the economy because federal ministers kept pushing their own agendas, and urged the government to engage the opposition, the PTI in particular.
The PML-N has not softened its position on the underlying question. Parliamentary affairs minister Tariq Fazal Chaudhry has said the party will make every effort to persuade the PPP to support a referendum on new provinces, and that Bhutto-Zardari should have approached the prime minister before criticising the government in public.
Copyright © 2021 Independent Pakistan | All rights reserved
