By Staff Reporter
ISLAMABAD: Pakistan’s overseas minister has served defamation notices on Punjab’s chief minister, Maryam Nawaz, and the province’s information minister, after refusing to retract or apologise for his allegations of corruption in the province.
Chaudhry Salik Hussain, a leader of the Pakistan Muslim League-Quaid (PML-Q), a smaller partner in the ruling coalition, said on Monday that his lawyers had sent the notices to Nawaz and to Azma Bokhari. He made the announcement on the same day he replied to the Rs5bn defamation notice the chief minister had served on him.
“Further, I have also sent through my legal counsel two legal notices for defamation. One to Maryam Nawaz Sharif and the other one to Azma Zahid Bokhari,” he said in a post on X.
In a separate post, he said: “A formal reply to the legal notice has been duly sent.” He added: “Attempts to intimidate through legal notices will neither silence nor deter me from raising concerns on matters of public interest and their well-being.”
Hussain repeated his claim that the province “continues to suffer from gross mismanagement and rampant corruption”, problems he said demanded a “little” self-reflection and accountability, “not intimidation”.
According to the reply, his lawyers argued that his remarks were “an expression of opinion on a matter that is fair and in the public interest”. They said the chief minister’s notice wrongly portrayed them as assertions of fact.
Even if they were statements of fact, the reply said, they would not amount to defamation, because defamation requires a false or untrue statement and his remarks were neither. It cited several public statements in which Nawaz herself acknowledged corruption in Punjab, and argued these supported his position.
The response described her notice as an attempt to “weaponise the law of defamation” to stifle legitimate criticism. It argued that governments and public authorities, particularly elected ones, cannot bring defamation actions under common law.
The demand for Rs5bn was “wholly baseless”, it said, and bore “no relation to any genuine claim for compensation”. It said the aim was to intimidate public representatives and warn others, including the press, against speaking about corruption in Punjab. The notice was “legally misconceived, untenable” and in places “verges on the absurd”, it added.
Hussain, it said, would not withdraw his statements, apologise, publish a retraction or pay anything.
The dispute began with an interview on a private news channel, broadcast on 2 November. In it Hussain praised his uncle, the former Punjab chief minister Chaudhry Pervez Elahi, and criticised the incumbent administration, saying he regularly heard complaints of corruption. He also questioned lavish government spending, in particular the use of an official aircraft, arguing that public representatives should be mindful of the country’s economic difficulties.
Nawaz, speaking at a public gathering in Attock, challenged him to produce evidence or face legal proceedings. On Tuesday 3 November she sent the Rs5bn notice and demanded that he retract his remarks. The six-page notice was issued by Punjab’s additional advocate general. It demanded an unconditional apology, a retraction and damages. It warned that failure to comply within seven days would lead to proceedings under the Punjab Defamation Act, 2024. She also asked why he remained a minister in a government he considered corrupt.
She and Bokhari said his displeasure stemmed from the refusal of his request to appoint a deputy commissioner of his choice in Gujrat. Hussain rejected the suggestion, saying the interview was recorded on 25 September, before the new deputy commissioner was appointed.
Bokhari, for her part, told him not to “bite the hand that feeds him”. Last week she noted that a week had passed without a reply to the notice, and challenged him to quit the ministry.
The row is awkward for the coalition because of the politics of Hussain’s own family. He is the younger son of the PML-Q president, Chaudhry Shujaat Hussain, and his family’s loyalties have diverged sharply since the 2022 ouster of Imran Khan’s government. His brother, Chaudhry Shafay Hussain, sits in Nawaz’s provincial cabinet as minister for industries, commerce and investment.
Asked on a television talk show about his brother’s position, Hussain said: “Reality is reality. I stand by it and will continue to.” He called the dragging of his family, and his father in particular, into the dispute a “below the belt” move, and said Bokhari’s fiery statements had made matters worse.
In separate television interviews, he rejected suggestions that his remarks were part of a conspiracy against the Punjab government or that the PML-Q was preparing to join an anti-government alliance. He said the next general election was about two and a half years away and asked which elections Nawaz was referring to. He has also complained that the provincial government withdrew his security after the interview.
Copyright © 2021 Independent Pakistan | All rights reserved
