Court orders clean cell and eye specialist for Bushra Bibi

Court orders clean cell and eye specialist for Bushra Bibi

By Staff Reporter

ISLAMABAD: An Islamabad court has ordered prison authorities to give Imran Khan’s wife a specialist eye examination and a clean cell, after her lawyer warned she risked losing her sight and told judges that snakes had been found where she is held.

The Islamabad High Court (IHC) issued the direction on Wednesday while hearing an urgent application on behalf of Bushra Bibi, the former first lady, who is serving a seven-year sentence in Adiala jail in Rawalpindi. It told the Islamabad advocate general, Naveed Hayat Malik, to ensure the order was carried out by the prison authorities.

The same bench, headed by Chief Justice Sardar Muhammad Sarfraz Dogar, adjourned for seven days the appeals that she and her husband have brought against their convictions in the £190m corruption case, giving his counsel more time to prepare arguments.

Khan, 74, the founder of the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) party and a former prime minister, has been in custody since August 2023. An accountability court in Islamabad sentenced him to 14 years in prison on 17 January 2025 in what is known as the Al-Qadir Trust case, and Bibi to seven. The case centres on allegations linked to a settlement involving funds recovered by Britain’s National Crime Agency. Khan has consistently denied wrongdoing.

Bibi’s application, filed on Monday, asked the court to call for her complete medical record and to order her immediate transfer to a specialised hospital. She had asked for that transfer, but the bench instead directed that a specialist doctor from a hospital examine her, that her cell be kept clean and that she be given all necessary medical facilities in line with jail rules.

Her lawyers say her sight has worsened badly. Affidavits submitted to the court state that she told them, after a meeting at the jail on 11 November, that her vision had been severely impaired in both eyes since an earlier operation. She could see only to a limited extent with spectacles, she said, and was virtually unable to see without them.

The affidavits add that she has been diagnosed with a mature cataract, that further surgery was expected on or around 15 November, and that doctors cautioned that an infection afterwards could cost her sight permanently. Her first eye operation was on 18 April, after which she was returned to Adiala.

Sardar Latif Khosa, her counsel, told the bench that her health needed immediate attention, particularly given the risk of infection after surgery. Reading from the application, he said seven small snakes had reportedly been found in her cell and killed by a prison official identified as Sibtain, and that the area had afterwards been sealed with cement. The petition also alleges that poor sanitation has let rats, cockroaches and centipedes into the cell. The allegations have not been independently verified.

Khosa argued that such conditions exposed his client to infection and made special precautions essential if she were operated on. He added that even if she were granted bail, she could remain in the court’s custody.

Justice Dogar said the court had noted the concerns and would ensure she received every facility permissible under prison rules. The difficulties set out in the application must not recur, he said, and he assured Khosa that the former first lady was in safe hands. He recalled that health-related matters had previously been referred to the Federal Constitutional Court, but said this application would be dealt with within the bench’s own jurisdiction.

The judge then turned to the main appeals, reminding Khosa that he had undertaken to begin arguments once he had met Khan. Khosa confirmed that he and Barrister Salman Safdar had visited the couple, as the court had directed, and had filed affidavits. Safdar will argue Khan’s appeal and Khosa Bibi’s.

Safdar also asked the bench to allow the hearings to be broadcast live, saying the case had drawn considerable public attention. He noted that the bench had called it a routine matter at the previous hearing, yet proceedings involving the former military ruler General Pervez Musharraf had been broadcast live, as had cases before the Supreme Court and high courts. He said he would file a formal application.

The appeals have stalled repeatedly. In July, the IHC granted what it called a final opportunity to the defence, warning that no further adjournment would be entertained if arguments were not presented at the next hearing. Defence lawyers have said they were denied access to their clients for long periods. Safdar met Khan on 2 November for the first time in seven months, and Bibi for the first time in 11, in a meeting that lasted 40 minutes. A longer meeting of nearly three hours followed on 11 November, after the IHC ordered jail authorities on 10 November to arrange it.

Khan’s sisters, Noreen Khan and Dr Uzma, were in the courtroom, along with PTI chairman Barrister Gohar Ali Khan and other party leaders. Prosecutor General of the National Accountability Bureau Sohail Nasir, prosecutors Javed Arshad and Rafay Maqsood, and Malik attended for the state. Security was tight inside and around the court.

Separately, Khan’s lawyer Khalid Yusuf Chaudhry served a legal notice on the Adiala jail superintendent demanding that the former prime minister be moved to Shifa International Hospital in Islamabad, in line with Supreme Court orders of 18 August. The notice, posted on the X account of the opposition alliance Tehreek-i-Tahafuz Ayin-i-Pakistan, said Khan had been taken to the state-run Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences, although the court had specified Shifa.

Chaudhry said Khan’s fundamental human, constitutional and legal rights must be protected.

“He should be allowed to meet his family members and wife, have audio and video contact with his sons, and be provided with newspapers, books and television, as well as an hour of daily outdoor walking and exercise,” the notice said.

It called keeping a prisoner in isolation and restricting his human contact on security grounds “unacceptable”.

“Such conduct violates the Constitution of Pakistan and domestic and international laws concerning prisoners’ rights,” it said.

The notice demanded that the superintendent move Khan to Shifa without delay, comply fully with the court’s orders and restore all his legal and human rights.

Copyright © 2021 Independent Pakistan | All rights reserved

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *